| W/L | Game | Score | Year | Tournament | Footage |
| L | Northern Illinois | 7-13 | 2012 | Glory Days | Watch Game |
| W | Bradley University | 13-6 | 2012 | Glory Days | Watch Game |
| W | Hanover | 13-2 | 2014 | D-3 Midwestern Invite | Watch Game |
| L | Kenyon Serf | 9-12 | 2014 | D-3 Midwestern Invite | Watch Game |
| L | Wisconsin-Parkside | 8-12 | 2014 | D-3 Midwestern Invite | Watch Game |
| W | Western Michigan (Game 1) | 11-9 | 2014 | Chicago Invite | Watch Game |
| L | Wisconsin-Parkside | 12-13 | 2014 | Chicago Invite | Watch Game |
| W | Eastern Illinois | 11-8 | 2014 | Chicago Invite | Watch Game |
| W | Missouri S&T | 13-5 | 2014 | Chicago Invite | Watch Game |
| L | North Park | 11-15 | 2014 | Sectionals | Watch Game |
| L | Wheaton | 10-11 | 2014 | Sectionals | Watch Game |
| L | Calvin | 6-12 | 2014 | Sectionals | Watch Game |
Olivet Nazarene University Ultimate Team 